OBJECTIVES: The study's objectives were to verify a threshold value for fet
al arterial oxygen saturation as the critical boundary for fetal compromise
during labor and to investigate a method of predicting acidosis caused by
hypoxemia.
STUDY DESIGN: In a multicenter study involving 3 German obstetric centers,
a total of 400 deliveries were monitored by fetal pulse oximetry (Nellcor-P
uritan-Bennett Model N-400 Oxygen Saturation Monitor and FS-14 Sensor; Nell
cor, Inc, Pleasanton, Calif). The durations of low (less than or equal to 3
0%), medium (31%-60%), and high (>60%) fetal arterial oxygen saturations du
ring the measurement were compared between neonates with a pH <7.15 Versus
greater than or equal to 7.15 and a base excess <-12 mmol/L Versus >-12 mmo
l/L in the umbilical artery post partum and in neonates with an Apgar score
<7 Versus greater than or equal to 7 by Mann-Whitney U test. In 121 of the
pulse oximetry measurements the durations of low, medium, and high fetal a
rterial oxygen saturations were measured from one fetal scalp blood samplin
g to the next and correlated with the change of scalp blood pH between samp
lings. Multiple regression analysis was performed to estimate the expected
change of pH between 2 fetal scalp blood samplings, and receiver operating
characteristic analysis was done to define a minimum duration of low fetal
arterial oxygen saturation values to exclude or predict a significant decli
ne of pH.
RESULTS: Neonates with a I-minute Apgar score <7 differed from those with 1
-minute Apgar score greater than or equal to 7 significantly in the duratio
n of low fetal arterial oxygen saturation but not in the durations of mediu
m and high fetal arterial oxygen saturations. The duration of low fetal art
erial oxygen saturation had been significantly longer in children with pH <
7.15 or base excess <-12 mmol/L in the umbilical artery compared with those
with a pH greater than or equal to 7.15 or base excess >-12 mmol/L. The du
ration of high fetal arterial oxygen saturation was significantly shorter f
or children with a pH <7.15 or base excess <12 mmol/L than for those with a
pH greater than or equal to 7.15 or base excess greater than or equal to 1
2 mmol/L. There was no difference in the groups with respect to the duratio
n of medium fetal arterial oxygen saturation values. The duration of low fe
tal arterial oxygen saturation proved to be the best predictor of a decline
of scalp pH between 2 fetal scalp blood samples. The pH declined significa
ntly with a longer duration of low fetal arterial oxygen saturation (0.02 p
er 10 minutes). No decrease of pH by more than 0.05 was observed unless fet
al arterial oxygen saturation had remained at less than or equal to 30% for
greater than or equal to 10 minutes.
CONCLUSION: An arterial oxygen saturation of 30% was confirmed as the criti
cal boundary for fetal compromise during labor. The development of acidosis
seems to be predictable by the duration of hypoxemia, as indicated by feta
l arterial oxygen saturation less than or equal to 30%.