Stationary phases with octadecyl groups have been prepared with different c
arbon content without and in the presence of water and characterized for th
eir selectivity for the shape of various polyaromatic hydrocarbons. It is s
hown that both a high hydrocarbon content and a good accessibility of the b
onded groups within the pores is required to achieve shape recognition for
PAH. High carbon content alone is not sufficient. The two tests for shape s
electivity proposed by Sander and Wise as well as by Tanaka are compared. I
n most cases the results are similar: A low selectivity with the Sander and
Wise test (alpha TBN/BaP < 1) corresponds to a high value with the Tanaka
test (alpha TRI/o-TER > 3). However, not in all cases the tests give corres
ponding answers. Further studies on molecular recognition are required.