OBJECTIVE - To evaluate the clinical effects of a comprehensive prepackaged
meal plan, incorporating the overall dietary guidelines of the American Di
abetes Association and other national health organizations, relative to tho
se of a self-selected diet based on exchange lists in free-living individua
ls with type 2 diabetes.
RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS - A total of 202 women and men (BMI less than o
r equal to 42 kg/m(2)) whose diabetes was treated with diet alone or an ora
l hypoglycemic agent were enrolled at 10 medical centers. After a dr-week b
aseline period, participants were randomized to a nutrient-fortified prepar
ed meal plan or a self-selected exchange-list diet for 10 weeks. On a calor
ic basis, both interventions were designed to provide 55-60% carbohydrate,
20-30% fat, and 15-20% protein. At intervals, 3-day food records were compl
eted, and body weight, glycemic control, plasma lipids, and blood pressure
were assessed.
RESULTS - Food records showed that multiple nutritional improvements were a
chieved with both diet plans. There were significant overall reductions in
body weight and BMI, fasting plasma glucose and serum insulin, fructosamine
, HbA(1c), total and LDI cholesterol, and blood pressure (P < 0.001 or bett
er for all). In general, differences in major end points between the diet p
lans were not statistically significant.
CONCLUSIONS - Glycemic control and cardiovascular risk factors improve in i
ndividuals with type 2 diabetes who consume diets in accordance with the Am
erican Diabetes Association guidelines. The prepared meal program was as cl
inically effective as the exchange-list diet. The prepared meal plan has th
e additional advantages of being easily prescribed and eliminating the comp
lexities of meeting the multiple dietary recommendations for type 2 diabete
s management.