Recent improvements in the treatment options for fungal disease of the
sinuses make rapid distinction between the syndromes of invasive and
noninvasive sinusitis necessary. On the basis of the extensive review
of the literature detailed here, we developed case-finding criteria fo
r the noninvasive syndrome of sinus mycetoma. Using these criteria, we
identified 20 cases of sinus mycetoma in the medical literature and c
ompared findings in these patients to those of five patients with myce
toma evaluated in our clinics. Like those in the literature, our patie
nts appeared immunocompetent and were often first seen for evaluation
of symptoms other than those usually associated with sinusitis. Two we
re first seen with a new-onset seizure disorder and one with nasal obs
truction alone, Patients from both groups more commonly had mycetoma i
n their maxillary sinuses, and fungus failed to grow from the cheesy,
grey-green, hyphae-rich material removed at the time of surgery. Clini
cal features in our five patients, which are not noted in published re
ports of sinus mycetoma, included frequent atopy, nasal polyps, calcif
ication within the sinus on computed tomography, and an excellent resp
onse to surgical treatment. Serendipitously, one patient had both alle
rgic fungal sinusitis and a mycetoma in the same sinus. On the basis o
f this experience, we have modified our case-finding criteria into pro
posed diagnostic criteria for sinus mycetoma. The elements of these cr
iteria are designed to: (1) exclude patients with invasive fungal sinu
sitis and (2) differentiate sinus mycetoma from other forms of noninva
sive fungal sinusitis on the basis of specific histopathologic finding
s. This study and the criteria presented reflect our view that sinus m
ycetoma represents a distinct but not necessarily isolated element in
the spectrum of noninvasive fungal disease of the sinuses.