Ke. Binkley et S. Kutcher, PANIC RESPONSE TO SODIUM LACTATE INFUSION IN PATIENTS WITH MULTIPLE CHEMICAL-SENSITIVITY SYNDROME, Journal of allergy and clinical immunology, 99(4), 1997, pp. 570-574
Background: Many patients who are first seen with what has been called
multiple chemical sensitivity syndrome (RIGS) experience symptoms sug
gestive of panic disorder including chest tightness, shortness of brea
th, palpitations, paresthesias, lightheadedness, and mental confusion,
Although such patients are often convinced that these symptoms reflec
t toxic effects of environmental ''chemicals;'' direct evidence of thi
s is lacking. To the contrary, a previous study has shown that some of
these individuals exhibit hyperventilation responses on exposure to n
onnoxious stimuli, and it has been suggested that the resulting bypoca
rbia accounts for their symptoms, We postulated that some patients wit
h self-identified MCS had an underlying condition similar to panic dis
order and would therefore demonstrate similar responses to provocative
challenges, such as sodium lactate infusion. Methods: Patients referr
ed to an allergy and clinical immunology service for evaluation of ''c
hemical sensitivity'' mere investigated to rule out underlying medical
conditions, including asthma, as a cause of their symptoms and we wer
e enrolled for study after giving informed consent. After a standardiz
ed psychiatric assessment was performed, patients underwent single-bli
nd intravenous infusions of normal saline solution (placebo) and sodiu
m lactate (which reproduces symptoms in individuals with underlying pa
nic disorder), All patients mere referred for independent psychiatric
assessment. Results: The standardized psychiatric assessment identifie
d four of five patients as meeting DSM III-R diagnostic criteria for p
anic disorder along with other depressive and/or anxiety-related disor
ders, All five patients with self-identified chemical sensitivity exhi
bited a positive symptomatic response to sodium lactate compared with
placebo infusion, Independent psychiatric assessment confirmed the dia
gnosis of panic disorder on the basis of DSM III-R criteria in each of
the five patients, Conclusions: These results suggest that MCS may ha
ve a neurobiologic basis similar, if not identical, to that of panic d
isorder, We speculate that treatments with demonstrated efficacy in pa
nic disorder may also be of benefit in MCS, and conversely, treatments
that reinforce anticipatory anxiety and avoidance behavior in patient
s with MCS may be detrimental.