M. Skov et al., Specific IgG subclass antibody pattern to Aspergillus fumigatus in patients with cystic fibrosis with allergic bronchopulmonary aspergillosis (ABPA), THORAX, 54(1), 1999, pp. 44-50
Background-IgG and Ige subclass antibodies to Aspergillus fumigatus (A fumi
gatus) were measured in a large population of patients with cystic fibrosis
to elucidate a putative antibody pattern specific for allergic bronchopulm
onary aspergillosis(ABPA).
Methods-An ELISA technique using water soluble somatic hyphal (WSSH) A fumi
gatus antigens and subclass specific monoclonal antibodies was used for cro
ss sectional quantification of IgG and IgG(1-4) subclass antibody levels in
the serum of 238 patients with cystic fibrosis and 107 healthy controls.
Results-In patients with cystic fibrosis persistently colonised with A fumi
gatus the subclass antibody levels were significantly increased compared wi
th patients with cystic fibrosis never or rarely colonised (p<0.001). The g
roup of patients persistently colonised with A fumigatus with ABPA (+Af+ABP
A) had significantly increased levels of IgG antibodies to A fumigatus (Af-
IgG) (median 69 ELISA units (EU) versus 31) and of subclasses Af-IgG(1) (91
versus 27), Af-IgG(2) (143 versus 56), and Af-IgG(4) antibodies (72 versus
20), but not of IgG(3) (17 versus 15), compared with the colonised patient
s without ABPA (+Af-ABPA). Patients with cystic fibrosis with no or only ra
re isolates A fumigatus without ABPA (-Af-ABPA) also had significantly incr
eased subclass antibody levels (Af-IgG(1) 9 versus 3, Af-IgG(2) 28 versus 5
, Af-IgG(4) 16 versus 4; p<0.001) compared with healthy controls. Low, alth
ough detectable, levels of antibodies were demonstrated in healthy controls
. ABPA seemed to occur independently of Pseudomonas aeruginosa infection. U
sing diagnostic cut off levels for ABPA, sensitivity and specificity were c
alculated. The highest specificity was found for IgG(4) (88%); sensitivity
was between 65% and 73%. The positive predictive values (PPV) were moderate
, whereas the negative predictive values (NPV) were high (96% in all subcla
sses except IgG(3) with 94%), PPV increased to 50% if IgG(1) as well as IgG
(2) and IgG(4) were included.
Conclusions-In a large number of unselected patients with cystic fibrosis s
ignificantly increased levels of Af-specific antibodies belonging to total
IgG and all four subclasses were found in all groups of patients compared w
ith healthy controls. In patients persistently colonised with A fumigatus t
hese levels were significantly higher than in non-colonised patients, and t
he significantly highest levels (with the exception of IgG(3)) were found i
n patients with ABPA. Using a sensitive ELISA technique, measurements of Ig
G and IgG subclass antibodies to A fumigatus might be of importance in the
management of ABPA, especially as a screening test to exclude the presence
of ABPA; other tests are needed to confirm the diagnosis.