About 30% of the carbon in terrestrial ecosystems is stored in northern wet
lands and boreal forest regions. Prevailing cold and wet soil conditions ha
ve largely been responsible for this carbon accumulation. It has been sugge
sted that a warmer and drier climate in these regions might increase the de
composition rate and, hence, release more CO2 to the atmosphere than at pre
sent. This study reports on the spatial variability and temperature depende
nce of the potential carbon release after incubating highly organic soils f
rom the European Arctic and Siberia at different temperatures. We found tha
t the decay potential, measured as CO2 production in laboratory experiments
, differed strongly within and among sites, particularly at higher soil tem
peratures. Furthermore, both the decay potential and its temperature respon
se decreased significantly with depth in the soil, presumably because the o
lder soils at deeper layers contained higher proportions of recalcitrant ca
rbon than the younger soil organic matter at the surface. These results hav
e implications for global models of potential feedbacks on climate change i
nferred from changes in the carbon balance of northern wetlands and tundra.
Firstly, because the decay potential of the organic matter varies locally
as well as regionally, predictions of how the tundra carbon balance may cha
nge will be unreliable if these are based on measurements at a few sites on
ly. Secondly, any increase in CO2 production may be transitional as both th
e carbon flux and its temperature sensitivity decrease when the most easily
degradable organic material near the soil surface has decomposed. Conseque
ntly, it is crucial to account for transient responses and regional differe
nces in the models of potential feedbacks on climate change from changed ca
rbon cycling in northern terrestrial ecosystems. (C) 1999 Elsevier Science
B.V.