To test whether scrub jays (Aphelocoma coerulescens) remember the contents
of food caches, in Experiment 1 birds cached peanuts and kibbles in two dis
tinct caching trays and recovered them 4 or 172 hr later. The relative ince
ntive value of the foods was manipulated by prefeeding one of the foods imm
ediately before cache recovery. Birds preferentially searched for non-prefe
d food caches even when the caches had been pilfered prior to the recovery
test. In Experiment 2, birds cached both foods in different sites within ea
ch tray, recovering peanuts from one tray and kibbles from the other tray 3
hr later. After prefeeding with one food, birds preferentially searched tr
ay sites in which they had cached but not retrieved the non-prefed food. Th
us jays remember the specific foods they cache and recover by a mnemonic pr
ocess that cannot be explained in terms of simple associations between the
foods and their cache locations.