Ni. Montana et al., (Evaluation of) Humoral and cellular immune response evaluation against Brucella abortus strain RB51 antigens in bovine, ARCH MED V, 30(2), 1998, pp. 109-123
In order to comparatively evaluate the type of immune response induced by p
urified structural Brucella abortus antigens as well as live vaccines, 14 c
riollo heifers, 19 months old, were randomly distributed in five experiment
al groups and immunised subcutaneously with: B. abortus purified outer memb
rane proteins (OMP-II), B. abortus OMP-II coupled to O-chain, viable B. abo
rtus strain RB51, viable B, abortus strain 19 (C19). A sterile saline solut
ion was used for the control group. Two months after vaccination the animal
s were challenged intramuscularly with reference virulent strain B. abortus
2308. 30 days after challenge the protection level was evaluated. The humo
ral immune response was evaluated using conventional Rose Bengal agglutinat
ion test, complement fixation test, radial immunodiffusion as well as ELISA
, western blot and dot blot assays at days 0, 8, 15, 30, 60 and 90. Additio
nally, the specific IgG2 isotype response was determined by double sandwich
ELISA. To evaluate cellular immune responses, lymphocyte proliferation was
measured by timidine incorporation and expressed as stimulation index (S.I
.), IFN-gamma activity by ELISA and CD4/CD8 ratio by fluorocitometry. Anima
ls vaccinated with live strains presented 100% protection against challenge
, while a 66% protection was observed in those vaccinated with purified ant
igens. The diagnostic advantage of B. abortus Strain RB51 was evidenced by
the lack of humoral immune responses against sLPS in all vaccinated groups
except for the strain 19 group. No significant differences (p>0.05) were de
tected in any of the groups by lymphoproliferation when stimulated in vitro
with purified OMP-II, O-chain or sLPS. When crude soluble RB51 protein was
used, S.I. turned significant (p<0.05) and indicated a better response ind
uced by the live vaccines. IFN-gamma-ELISA tests with stimulated tissue cul
tures performed better when measured 72 hour after antigen exposure. In ref
erence to the experimental groups, higher levels were detected in the group
s immunised with live vaccine, mainly strain 19. When CD4/CD8 ratio were co
nsidered the values were constant during the observation and no differences
were observed. The results confirm that B, abortus strain RB51 induced lev
el of protection similar to strain 19, and had the advantage of differentia
l diagnosis. Purified antigens OMP-II and OMP-II-O-chain, induced a lower l
evel of protection but they performed similar to replicating vaccines indic
ating the immunodominance of OMP-II, but suggesting the need of multiple do
ses to reach the same level of protection. It is proposed that the protecti
on observed in animals vaccinated with B. abortus RB51 is the result of sti
mulation of both T CD4 Th1 and CD8 lymphocytes by the peptides of the outer
membrane proteins.