We are proceeding at great speed over difficult terrain, towards an unknown
, unquantifiable goal. The speed reflects genuine public concerns and a sen
se of urgency. The difficult terrain reflects the complexity of forest prac
tices. Moreover, forests are simultaneously the richest terrestrial ecosyst
ems on earth and major contributors to social infrastructure. Slipperiness
of the goal reflects the fact that biological diversity is not a thing, but
a cluster of concepts. To a large extent we have substituted motion for ac
complishment To substitute accomplishment for motion I suggest five steps:
1) separate two big issues Glow much old growth is enough and how we practi
ce forestry); 2) create a credible, interim operational goal for biodiversi
ty tit is possible); 3) confront the issue of habitat distribution (Canada
is well positioned); 4) focus on total amount of habitat rather than its di
stribution (many concerns about the latter are mislead); and 5) slow down a
nd think (the alternative is dangerous).