Research suggests that cellular phone use while driving increases the risk
of an auto accident by a factor of 4. Additionally, it has yet to be shown
that hands-free phones (such as those which use voice-activated dialing sys
tems (VADS)) provide any added safety benefit over manual phones. Since it
has been shown that driving performance is degraded during complex conversa
tions especially under demanding driving conditions it makes sense to desig
n the VADS interface to be as intuitive and simple to navigate as possible
in order to reduce the risk of an accident. This paper presents the results
of an investigation of a commercially available voice-activated dialing sy
stem under simulated driving conditions and provides recommendations for im
provement of its call hows and user-interface design. Considering the call
flow findings, we conclude that the voice phone book metaphor provides an a
dequate mental map which helps users navigate the menu hierarchy with some
minor exceptions. With regard to the user interface design findings, we con
clude that any VADS could be improved by following the principles of conver
sational speech such as avoiding repetition and being flexible in its handl
ing of interruptions.