M. Mattson et Pm. Buzzanell, Traditional and feminist organizational communication ethical analyses of messages and issues surrounding an actual job loss case, J APPL COMM, 27(1), 1999, pp. 49-72
The difficulties of studying organizational communication ethics often dete
r researchers and practitioners from addressing ethics in the workplace. In
this article, we present an actual job loss case then analyze it from Both
traditional and feminist organizational communication ethics approaches. A
lthough Redding's (1996) classification of unethical messages offers a usef
ul starting point for ethical analyses, our discussion displays the ways in
which his system is incomplete and aligned with managerial biases. We deve
lop a feminist organizational communication ethical approach by adapting St
einer's (1997) broad outline of feminist ethical concerns to messages and m
essage-related practices. By contrasting these two ethical systems, we offe
r a more coherent and illuminating framework for problematic issues and fut
ure courses of action.