This paper offers an analysis of Middle English Alliterative Verse in terms
of Prosodic Metrics (Golston and Riad 1995, 1997a, b, 1998) using the rank
ed and violable constraints of Optimality Theory (Prince and Smolensky 1993
). The analysis uses purely phonological constraints without recourse to la
nguage-specific or meter-specific constraints and without an abstract metri
cal template (Helsloot 1997). I show that the number of tokens per metrical
type correlates with phonological well-formedness in one of five areas: bi
narity, weight, alignment, identity, and rhythm. In addition, I show that p
oems written in this meter have no perfectly metrical lines in them: every
line violates some constraint because absolute metrical well-formedness is
not possible given the constraints in this type of meter. Gradient well-for
medness in meter (Youmans 1989) is shown to be both demonstrable and formal
izable.