One of the most controversial results of the CLIMAP(1,2) project's reconstr
uction of past sea surface temperature (SST) is that large areas of the sub
tropical Pacific Ocean were warmer during the last glacial period than they
are today. This finding has important implications because SST patterns at
low to subtropical latitudes strongly influence climate, and SST changes a
re closely linked with climate fluctuations(3-5). Until now, a lack of well
-preserved, high-resolution marine sediment cores from the region has hinde
red efforts to confirm these unexpectedly high ice-age SST estimates. Here
we use both the oxygen-isotope compositions and species assemblages of plan
ktonic foraminifera in a shallow-water core with high deposition rates near
Hawaii to estimate glacial SST of the subtropical North Pacific Ocean, Con
trary to the CLIMAP results(2), our data indicate that the annual average S
ST in this region was similar to 2 degrees C cooler during the last glaciat
ion than it is today, These results help to reconcile the marine SST record
with inferences drawn from snowline depressions on Hawaii during the last
glacial(3,6), and should ultimately yield improved estimates of global clim
ate sensitivity by providing important new constraints on climate model sim
ulations of ice-age cycles.