Ma. Ellenbogen et al., Acute tryptophan depletion in healthy young women with a family history ofmajor affective disorder, PSYCHOL MED, 29(1), 1999, pp. 35-46
Background. Acute tryptophan depletion (ATD), a means of reducing brain ser
otonin synthesis, lowers mood in normal males with a multi-generational fam
ily history of major affective disorder (MAD) and in normal women devoid of
any family history of psychiatric illness. As both a family history of MAD
and female sex are factors predisposing to depression, the hypothesis that
a mood lowering response to ATD may reflect a susceptibility to depression
was further investigated in young women with an extensive, multi-generatio
nal family history of MAD. In addition, the temporal stability of mood chan
ge following repeated trials of ATD was also assessed in this study.
Methods. To deplete tryptophan, a tryptophan deficient amino acid mixture w
as ingested on two separate occasions. The control treatment, administered
on a third occasion, was a nutritionally balanced amino acid mixture contai
ning tryptophan.
Results. A marked lowering of plasma tryptophan (85-90%) was achieved by bo
th depletions. In comparison to the balanced condition, family history posi
tive (FH +) women showed no lowering of mood to either the first or second
ATD (N = 13) and N = 12, respectively). Mood change between the two ATD tri
als (N = 13) exhibited poor temporal stability.
Conclusions, These results may indicate that serotonin responsiveness is no
t an important characteristic of vulnerability to depression in these women
. Alternately, these negative results may be due to the exclusion of a larg
e number of FR + women who had already experienced an episode of depression
, resulting in the selection of a. biased FH+ sample who are resistant to t
he mood lowering effects of ATD.