Background. Research conducted in primary care settings has demonstrated th
at effective communication enhances patient recall of information, complian
ce, satisfaction, psychologic well-being, and biomedical outcomes. However,
surgeons face communication challenges that are unique to the surgical sit
uation. This study provides the first description of routine communication
Between community-practicing surgeons ann their patients.
Methods. Audiotapes of 676 routine office visits with 29 general surgeons a
nd 37 orthopedic surgeons were coded for structure and content. Descriptive
analysis of quantitative data is supplemented by illustrative examples of
dialog selected to represent typical patterns of communication.
Results. The mean visit length was 13 minutes. Surgeons talked more than pa
tients, with typical surgical cal consultations containing relatively high
amounts of patient education and counseling. Consultations had a narrow bio
medical focus with little discussion of the psychologic aspects of patient
problems. The affective tone of visits was generally positive, with few ins
tances of overt criticism or disagreement by either party. However, surgeon
s infrequently expressed empathy toward patients, and social conversation w
as brief.
Conclusions. The study underscores the differences in Both the content and
process of routine surgical visits compared with primary care visits. On th
e basis of this work, it seems particularly important for surgeons to devel
op skills that enhance patient education and counseling. Further research i
s needed to understand the influences of surgeons' communication on patient
behavioral, psychologic, and biomedical outcomes.