Sa. Burchill et al., Improved methods using the reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reactionto detect tumour cells, BR J CANC, 79(5-6), 1999, pp. 971-977
Reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PGR) is increasingly us
ed to detect small numbers of circulating tumour cells, though the clinical
benefit remains controversial. The largest single contributing factor to t
he controversy of its value is the different approaches to sample processin
g. The aim of this study was to compare the sensitivity and reproducibility
of RT-PCR for the detection of tumour cells after four commonly used diffe
rent methods of sample processing. Using RT-PCR, one tumour cell spiked in
2 mi of whole blood was detected after analysis of separated mononuclear ce
ll RNA, whole blood total or poly-A(+) RNA. No false positives were identif
ied with any method. However, the reproducibility of tumour cell detection
was reduced after isolation of the mononuclear cell fraction. Only analysis
of poly-A(+) RNA had a sensitivity of 100% in all the cell spiking experim
ents. In patient blood samples, analysis of poly-A(+) RNA increased the num
ber of blood samples positive for tyrosine hydroxylase (TH) mRNA compared w
ith those positive after analysis of total RNA. This may reflect high level
s of cDNA reducing the efficiency of the PCR. Isolation of poly-A(+) RNA in
creases the sensitivity and reproducibility of tumour cell detection in per
ipheral blood.