The aims of this investigation were to compare quantitative with qualitativ
e analysis of fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) centromere signals i
n interphase breast cancer cell nuclei and to evaluate the possible clinica
l utility of detecting numerical abnormalities of chromosomes 11 and 17 by
FISH in the preoperative prediction of breast cancer histological grade. Co
mmercial digoxigenin-labeled centromere probes to chromosomes 11 and 17 wer
e hybridized to 69 malignant aspirates with histological follow-up. Aspirat
es were categorized as disomic or aneusomic for chromosomes 11 and 17 quali
tatively; a subset of aspirates was also analyzed quantitatively. The quant
itative and qualitative approaches resulted in almost identical categorisat
ion. There was a significant association between the qualitative categoriza
tion of aspirates as aneusomic or disomic, the histological grade of the ex
cised tumours (P=.0695, n = 69), and the cytological grade of the clinical
aspirates (P =.006, n = 35). Although histological grade III tumors were al
most invariably polysomic for one or both chromosomes, polysomy was also de
tected in grade I and IT tumors. Qualitative FISH analysis was shown to be
more sensitive than cytological grading in predicting histological grade II
I but was of lower specificity and was therefore not clinically useful. HUM
PATHOL 30:137-144. Copyright (C) 1999 by W.B. Saunders Company.