Background. Functional impairment over time is a necessary condition for th
e diagnosis of dementia. Increasingly, it is recognized that rates of decli
ne may not follow a linear progression. This variability may indicate that
dementia in Alzheimer's disease represents disease rather than inevitable a
ging. In order to investigate decline in function in dementia, we developed
a model of the rate of decline in functions in Alzheimer's disease and in
other dementias in comparison with normal aging.
Methods. Secondary analysis of a cross-sectional, representative sample of
Canadians aged 65 and older (N = 2,914) was performed. We calculated a meas
ure identified as an impairment index, defined as the probability of the oc
currences of an impairment or disability in a structured clinical examinati
on.
Results. The rate of functional decline varies for different diagnostic gro
ups and increases with severity of the disease. The distribution for the ra
te of decline in dementia is distinct from that in aging without cognitive
impairment. In those without cognitive impairment, the distribution is expo
nential. Elderly persons with dementia of any type showed a log-normal dist
ribution.
Conclusions. The difference in the distributions between aging with and wit
hout dementia likely reflects fundamental differences in the processes of d
ecline in functions in the two groups. This suggests that the declines seen
in persons with dementia are distinct from normal aging. It also has impli
cations for the testing of antidementia medications, in that modeling treat
ment effects based on an assumption of linear decline is likely to be flawe
d.