J. Scullion et al., The effectivity of arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi from high input conventional and organic grassland and grass-arable rotations, PLANT SOIL, 204(2), 1998, pp. 243-254
The effectivity of arbuscular mycorrhizal spores in promoting growth of All
ium ameloprasum L. cv. Musselburgh and Trifolium repens L. cv. Menna was te
sted for inocula from three soil series under long term organic or intensiv
e, conventional grass and grass-arable rotations. For two soil series, Alli
um responses to inocula from soils recently converted to organic fanning we
re also assessed. Finally, Trifolium root fragments were used to inoculate
Allium so as to evaluate responses to this inoculation procedure. Plants we
re sown into previously sterilised, matched soils from organic farms with n
o nutrient input. Mycorrhizal treatments generally increased growth for All
ium. However, for Trifolium, infection decreased growth in the most fertile
soil and gave an increase only in the least fertile. In the least fertile
soil, inocula from organic farms were more effective than those from conven
tional farms. For Trifolium (all soils) and for Allium (least fertile soil)
, there was evidence of more efficient uptake of phosphorus in plants inocu
lated with spores from organic farms. The pattern of Allium response to ino
culation with spores from conventional, conversion and organic sources was
not consistent between soil type, but there was evidence of lower root infe
ction for conversion compared with organic inocula and of a trend towards h
igher infectivity as the time period under organic management increased. In
oculating Allium with AMF root fragments produced a plant response similar
to that obtained when spores were used, confirming that spore viability was
not the sole factor influencing AMF effectivity in earlier experiments. In
tensive farming practices may reduce the effectiveness of indigenous arbusc
ular mycorrhizal populations, particularly where fertiliser inputs are high
and inherent fertility is low. This could have practical implications wher
e high input farms are converted to organic management.