We use Monte Carlo simulations to study in detail the propagation of light
in a plane-parallel medium containing scattering particles. In particular,
we compute the forward and backward average pathlength parameters (FAPP and
BAPP, respectively) of four-flux radiative transfer models as functions of
the optical depth. Strong dependence on the single scattering albedo and p
hase function asymmetry is found for both quantities. In general the values
of the FAPP decrease with increasing absorption, whereas the opposite occu
rs for the BAPP. A similar effect is produced when changing from isotropic
phase functions to phase functions with a large asymmetry in the forward di
rection. We present analytical results for the asymptotic values of the FAP
P and BAPP as functions of albedo for the particular case of isotropic scat
tering. Our results differ markedly from the predictions obtained recently
with two multiple-scattering models by Vargas and Niklasson [J. Opt. Sec. A
m. A 14, 2243 (1997); Appl. Opt. 36, 3735 (1997)]. The differences found po
int out the intrinsic limitations of these models. (C) 1999 Optical Society
of America.