The existing recommendation to avoid harvesting alfalfa during a critical f
all rest period, based on calendar dates, is under review in Canada and adj
acent areas of the United States. The effect on yield and persistence of fo
ur fall cutting management treatments (based on cumulative growing degree-d
ays between harvests) was investigated for two cultivars of alfalfa (Medica
go sativa L. 'Apica' and 'Oneida VR') at five sites in Atlantic Canada. The
average seasonal DM yield for the five sites in the first production year
was 1.6 to 2.3 t ha(-1) greater with an additional harvest as compared with
the two-harvest system (Truro, Nappan, Fredericton, and Charlottetown) and
the one-harvest system in St. John's. Seasonal DM yield benefits were redu
ced over time; by the third production year, there was no increase in seaso
nal DM yield with an additional harvest. The seasonal DM yield increased wi
th increasing the interval between the final harvest and the previous one.
Taking an additional harvest resulted in higher winter plant mortality betw
een the first and second production years in Truro and Nappan, and the thir
d and fourth production years in St. John's. At the other two sites (Charlo
ttetown and Fredericton), and for the first three production years in St. J
ohn's, winter plant mortality was unchanged with an additional harvest but
regrowth potential in the following year was reduced. At the two sites that
experienced a severe winter (Nappan and Truro), the cultivar Oneida VR was
more adversely affected by the additional harvest than Apica. Our results
indicate that in Atlantic Canada, taking an additional harvest increases th
e risk of winterkill. If an additional harvest is to be taken, increasing t
he interval between the final harvest and the previous one to at least 500
growing degree-days will decrease the risk of winterkill and might have a p
ositive effect on next year's regrowth.