Objective: Tuberculosis (TB) is the commonest HIV-related opportunistic inf
ection in many developing countries and is thought to be a frequent underly
ing cause of HIV-associated wasting. We have used reference water dilution
methods to examine the body composition changes associated with TB and to a
ssess the severity and pattern of wasting.
Methods: The study was conducted at a charitable support house for poor and
homeless HIV-infected people in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. Male patients who
were HIV-positive and receiving treatment for active TB (HIVTB+) and HIV-in
fected controls without TB (HIVTB-) were studied. Total body water (TBW) an
d extracellular water (ECW) were measured by giving oral doses of deuterium
oxide and sodium bromide, respectively, and determining enrichment in plas
ma after 4 hours. Intracellular water (ICW), body cell mass (BCM), lean bod
y mass (LBM) and fat mass were calculated from these parameters using stand
ard equations.
Results: HIVTB+ (n = 11) and HIVTB- (n = 12) groups were similar in age, he
ight, CD4 count and HIV risk factors. HIVTB+ men had significantly lower me
an ICW (13.2 Versus 16.6 kg; p = .02) and BCM (18.4 versus 23.0 kg; p = .02
), a relative expansion of ECW (35.0 versus 30.0 L/kg body weight; p = .04)
, and small and nonsignificant reductions in total body weight (58.0 versus
62.1 kg; p = .26), LBM (45.5 versus 47.7 kg; p = .33) and fat mass (12.5 v
ersus 14.4 kg; p = .51) compared with HIVTB- controls. BCM in the HIVTB+ gr
oup was similar to reference values for severe malnutrition. The relative d
epletion of BCM appeared excessive in comparison with reference values for
uncomplicated starvation.
Conclusion: The nutritional status of HIVTB+ patients was significantly wor
se than HIVTB- patients. Body weight and LBM underestimated the nutritional
deficit, and measurement of BCM is therefore necessary to appreciate the e
xtent of malnutrition in such patients. Malnutrition in HIVTB+ patients is
severe and may therefore contribute to decreased survival. Hypermetabolism
appears to play a role in the wasting process in patients coinfected with H
IV and TB.