H. Nozaki et al., PHYLOGENETIC ANALYSIS OF YAMAGISHIELLA AND PLATYDORINA (VOLVOCACEAE, CHLOROPHYTA) BASED ON RBCL GENE-SEQUENCES, Journal of phycology, 33(2), 1997, pp. 272-278
Yamagishiella, based on Pandorina unicocca Rayburn et Starr is disting
uished from Eudorina by its isogamous sexual reproduction, whereas Pla
tydorina exhibits anisogamous sexual reproduction. In the present stud
y, rue sequenced the large subunit of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carbox
ylase/oxygenase (rbcL) genes from five Japanese and North American str
ains of Y. unicocca (Rayburn et Stair) Nozaki, true Platydorina caudat
a Kofoid strains, and two strains of Eudorina unicocca G. M. Smith, as
well as eight related colonial and unicellular species. Phylogenetic
trees were constructed based on these sequence data and on previously
published rbcL gene sequences from 23 volvocalean species in order to
deduce phylogenetic relationships within the colonial Volvocales, with
particular regard to the phylogenetic positions and status of the gen
era Yamagishiella and Platydorina. Two robust monophyletic groups of t
he anisogamous/oogamous volvocacean species were resolved in the maxim
um-parsimony tree as well as in the neighbor-joining distance tree. On
e of the two groups comprises three species of Volvox section Volvox,
whereas the other is composed of other sections of Volvox as well as o
f all the species of Eudorina and Pleodorina. Platydorina, however, wa
s positioned outside these two monophyletic groups. Therefore, derivat
ion of the Platydorina lineage may be earlier than that of such anisog
amous/oogamous groups, or origin of ''anisogamy with sperm, packets''
in Platydorina may De independent of sperm packet evolution in Eudorin
a, Pleodorina, and Volvox. It was also resolved with high bootstrap va
lues that all of the Y. unicocca strains form a monophyletic group pos
itioned outside the large monophyletic group including Eudorina and Pl
eodorina. These reject the possibility of the reverse evolution of iso
gamy from anisogamy to give rise to Yamagishiella within the lineage o
f Eudorina.