F. De Vathaire et al., Second malignant neoplasms after a first cancer in childhood: temporal pattern of risk according to type of treatment, BR J CANC, 79(11-12), 1999, pp. 1884-1893
The variation in the risk of solid second malignant neoplasms (SMN) with ti
me since first cancer during childhood has been previously reported. Howeve
r, no study has been performed that controls for the distribution of radiat
ion dose and the aggressiveness of past chemotherapy, which could be respon
sible for the observed temporal variation of the risk. The purpose of this
study was to investigate the influence of the treatment on the long-term pa
ttern of the incidence of solid SMN after a first cancer in childhood. We s
tudied a cohort of 4400 patients from eight centres in France and the UK, P
atients had to be alive 3 years or more after a first cancer treated before
the age of 17 years and before the end of 1985. For each patient in the co
hort, the complete clinical, chemotherapy and radiotherapy history was reco
rded. For each patient who had received external radiotherapy, the dose of
radiation received by 151 sites of the body were estimated. After a mean fo
llow-up of 15 years, 113 children developed a solid SMN, compared to 12.3 e
xpected from general population rates. A similar distribution pattern was o
bserved among the 1045 patients treated with radiotherapy alone and the 206
4 patients treated with radiotherapy plus chemotherapy; the relative risk,
but not the excess absolute risk, of solid SMN decreased with time after fi
rst treatment; the excess absolute risk increased during a period of at lea
st 30 years after the first cancer. This pattern remained after controlling
for chemotherapy and for the average dose of radiation to the major sites
of SMN. It also remained when excluding patients with a first cancer type o
r an associated syndrome known to predispose to SMN. When compared with rad
iotherapy alone, the addition of chemotherapy increases the risk of solid S
MN after a first cancer in childhood, but does not significantly modify the
variation of this risk during the time after the first cancer.