Over the East 15 years, a number of studies in the mass communication liter
ature have tested hypotheses about viewers' emotional reactions to frighten
ing movies or TV programs. An assumption seems to be that self-reports of n
egative emotion are adequate for testing hypotheses about emotional respons
es. This study challenges that assumption in arguing for an alternative pos
ition that self-report responses provide only a partial picture of emotiona
l response. By including data on physiological arousal, a more complete and
sometimes different view of emotional responses emerges. Participants were
either repressors or nonrepressors. Consistent with research on the repres
sive coping style, this study revealed that repressors who reported low lev
els of negative affect in. response to a frightening film exhibited signifi
cantly higher physiological arousal than did nonrepressors. These results s
uggest that for repressors, low levels of self-reported negative affect may
not provide a complete picture of their emotional experience. Implications
and future directions for research are discussed.