Hk. Roscoe et al., Slant column measurements of O-3 and NO2 during the NDSC intercomparison of zenith-sky UV-visible spectrometers in June 1996, J ATMOS CH, 32(2), 1999, pp. 281-314
In June 1996, 16 UV-visible sensors from 11 institutes measured spectra of
the zenith shy for more than 10 days. Spectra were analysed in real-time to
determine slant column amounts of O-3 and NO2, Spectra of Hg lamps and las
ers were measured, and the amount of NO;? in a cell was determined by each
spectrometer. Some spectra were re-analysed after obvious errors were found
. Slant columns were compared in two ways: by examining regression analyses
against comparison instruments over the whole range of solar zenith angles
; and by taking fractional differences from a comparison instrument at sola
r zenith angles between 85 degrees and 91 degrees. Regression identified wh
ich pairs of instruments were most consistent, and so which could be used a
s universal comparison instruments. For O-3, regression slopes for the whol
e campaign agreed within 5% for most instruments despite the use of differe
nt cross-sections and wavelength intervals, whereas similar agreement was o
nly achieved for NO2 when the same cross-sections and wavelength intervals
were used and only one half-day's data was analysed. Mean fractional differ
ences in NO2 from a comparison instrument fall within +/-7% (I-sigma) for m
ost instruments, with standard deviations of the mean differences averaging
4.5%. Mean differences in O-3 fall within +/-2.5% (I-sigma) for most instr
uments, with standard deviations of the mean differences averaging 2%. Meas
urements of NO2 in the cell had similar agreement to measurements of NO2 in
the atmosphere, but for some instruments measurements with cell and atmosp
here relative to a comparison instrument disagreed by more than the error b
ars.