Ca. Schalley et al., Characterization of self-assembling encapsulation complexes in the gas phase and solution, J AM CHEM S, 121(10), 1999, pp. 2133-2138
The interaction of quaternary ammonium ion guests with self-assembling host
s was examined by H-1 NMR and ESI-MS experiments. The hosts consist of four
identical, self-complementary subunits, reversibly joined in a capsular as
sembly through hydrogen bonding. Both approaches show the ammonium ions to
be encapsulated, held within the hollow shell of the capsule. Competition e
xperiments with a series of different guest ions reveal a characteristic si
ze selectivity. The NMR and MS methods are complementary: MS easily reveals
the formation of heterotetramers from different subunits that could not be
determined by NMR, while NMR allowed competitive encapsulations of neutral
and ionic guests that were not possible to detect with MS. These competiti
on experiments gave a lower limit of ca. 3.6 kcal/mol for the contribution
of cation-pi interactions involved in the encapsulation of the ionic guests
.