Dl. Zoran et al., WHEAT BRAN DIET REDUCES TUMOR-INCIDENCE IN A RAT MODEL OF COLON-CANCER INDEPENDENT OF EFFECTS ON DISTAL LUMINAL BUTYRATE CONCENTRATIONS, The Journal of nutrition, 127(11), 1997, pp. 2217-2225
To investigate the effects of dietary fibers in colonic luminal physio
logy and their role in the prevention of colon cancer, a study was con
ducted using two diet groups and two treatment groups in a 2 x 2 facto
rial design. The two diets differed only in the type of dietary fiber,
wheat bran and oat bran, and the two treatments were injection with t
he colon-specific carcinogen azoxymethane, or saline, as a control, Th
ere were 34 rats in the carcinogen-injected groups and 11 saline-injec
ted rats per diet group. The goal of the study was to determine if a m
oderate consumption (6 g/100 g diet) of wheat bran or oat bran would a
lter the development of colonic tumors in this rat model of colon canc
er, and if the differences in tumor incidence were correlated to lumin
al butyrate concentrations, luminal pH or fecal bulk, Short-chain fatt
y acid concentrations (SCFA) were measured in feces during the first h
alf of the study (the promotion phase of tumor development) and again
at the end of the study. Rats consuming oat bran had greater body weig
hts (P < 0.002), produced much larger concentrations of all SCFA, incl
uding butyrate, in both the proximal and distal colon (P < 0.0001), ha
d more acidic luminal pH values (P < 0.0001), but also had significant
ly more development of colon tumors (P < 0.03), Alternatively, rats co
nsuming wheat bran produced more typical molar ratios of the SCFA (65:
10:20), had a relatively greater concentration of butyrate than propio
nate, and produced a larger volume (P < 0.05) and more bulky stool tha
n the rats fed oat bran, The results of this study support other evide
nce that an acidic luminal pH is not protective in and of itself, and
that diets containing wheat bran are protective against colon cancer d
evelopment, In addition, these data show that large luminal butyrate c
oncentrations in the distal colon alone, as were present in the rats c
onsuming oat bran diets, are not protective of tumor development.