CHANGES IN TOTAL-BODY FAT DURING THE HUMAN REPRODUCTIVE-CYCLE AS ASSESSED BY MAGNETIC-RESONANCE-IMAGING, BODY-WATER DILUTION, AND SKINFOLD THICKNESS - A COMPARISON OF METHODS
A. Sohlstrom et E. Forsum, CHANGES IN TOTAL-BODY FAT DURING THE HUMAN REPRODUCTIVE-CYCLE AS ASSESSED BY MAGNETIC-RESONANCE-IMAGING, BODY-WATER DILUTION, AND SKINFOLD THICKNESS - A COMPARISON OF METHODS, The American journal of clinical nutrition, 66(6), 1997, pp. 1315-1322
Total body fat and fat-free mass were assessed by magnetic resonance i
maging (TBFMRI and FFMMRI) in 11-16 healthy Swedish women before pregn
ancy and 5-10 d and 2, 6, and 12 mo after delivery. On these occasions
, TBF was also measured by the body water dilution (TBFBWD) and skinfo
ld-thickness (TBFSFT) techniques. The results were used to compare cha
nges in TBFSFT and TBFBWD during reproduction with changes in TBFMRI.
TBFBWD was 1.5-4.0 kg higher than TBFMRI and at all postpartum measure
ments the difference between these estimates increased significantly w
ith increased body fat content. This difference was also significantly
higher 6 mo after delivery than it was 2 and 12 mo postpartum. The po
ssibility that this was due to variations in the degree of hydration o
f FFM postpartum was considered. TBFSFT was 1.7-3.1 kg higher than TBF
MRI and this difference increased with increasing body fat content. Th
e agreement between changes in TBFMRI and TBFSFT was different during
different times in the reproductive cycle and was also influenced by t
he amount of fat lost or gained. The findings thus suggest that there
is a risk for bias when changes in TBF during reproduction are estimat
ed by the skinfold-thickness technique as well as by isotope dilution.