INTERLABORATORY COMPARISON STUDY FOR THE DETERMINATION OF THE FUSARIUM MYCOTOXINS DEOXYNIVALENOL IN WHEAT AND ZEARALENONE IN MAIZE USING DIFFERENT METHODS
R. Schuhmacher et al., INTERLABORATORY COMPARISON STUDY FOR THE DETERMINATION OF THE FUSARIUM MYCOTOXINS DEOXYNIVALENOL IN WHEAT AND ZEARALENONE IN MAIZE USING DIFFERENT METHODS, Fresenius' journal of analytical chemistry, 359(6), 1997, pp. 510-515
Seventeen laboratories from six different countries, using their usual
in-house methods, participated in an interlaboratory comparison test
for the determination of the Fusarium mycotoxins deoxynivalenol (DON)
in wheat and zearalenone (ZON) in maize. The toxins generally were ext
racted from maize and wheat employing mixtures of water, acidified wat
er with an organic solvent or even pure water (for DON). While partici
pants who used enzyme linked immune sorbent assays (ELISA) for the det
ermination of DON did not perform any clean-up? various techniques wer
e applied for the purification of raw extracts (e.g. liquid/liquid ext
raction, solid phase extraction (SPE), immune affinity chromatography
(IAC)). For the final separation/quantification step either high perfo
rmance liquid chromatography (HPLC) (mostly for ZON), gas chromatograp
hy (GC) (for DON) or ELISA were employed by participants. The aim of t
his study was to obtain information about the state of the art of myco
toxin analysis in cereals and to support a knowledge and experience ex
change between the participating laboratories in the field of mycotoxi
n analysis. For each mycotoxin 5 different sample types were distribut
ed, standard solutions (10.10 mu g/ml ZON in methanol, 10.09 mu g/ml D
ON in ethyl acetate), blank materials, spiked samples (75.1 mu g/kg an
d 378.3 mu g/kg ZON in maize, 126.2 mu g/kg and 2519 mu g/kg DON in wh
eat) and naturally contaminated maize and wheat. Coefficients of varia
tion (CV) between laboratory mean results (outliers excluded) ranged f
rom 6.2 to 27.7% for ZON and from 18.9 to 30.0% for DON. Except for th
e maize samples spiked at 75.1 mu g/kg ZON the overall means (outliers
rejected) statistically could not be distinguished from the respectiv
e target values. Average recoveries of the reported results ranged fro
m 87.7 to 96.2% for ZON and from 94.2 to 108.5% for DON.