Cp. Qualls, THE EFFECTS OF REPRODUCTIVE MODE AND CLIMATE ON REPRODUCTIVE SUCCESS IN THE AUSTRALIAN LIZARD, LERISTA-BOUGAINVILLII, Journal of herpetology, 31(1), 1997, pp. 60-65
The most widely accepted hypothesis invokes cold climates as the selec
tive force responsible for the evolution of viviparity in reptiles. Th
e ''cold climate'' hypothesis proposes that viviparity is adaptive in
cold climates because developing embryos experience warmer temperature
s in utero (through maternal thermoregulation) than they would in a ne
st. Most authors have assumed that these warmer incubation temperature
s provide an advantage by protecting embryos from lethally low tempera
tures or by allowing them to hatch before the onset of winter. Thus, t
he ''cold climate'' hypothesis (at least in its traditional form) purp
orts that viviparity evolves in cold climates because females that ret
ain their developing offspring in utero will have greater reproductive
success than females that lay their eggs in a nest. To test this hypo
thesis, I conducted a reciprocal transplant experiment using the repro
ductively bimodal Australian lizard, Lerista bougainvillii. Gravid ovi
parous and viviparous females were transplanted into field enclosures
in both a ''hot'' and a ''cold'' climate, to monitor the effects of cl
imate on their reproductive success. The live-bearers had higher repro
ductive success than the egg-layers in both climates, but reproductive
success did not differ between the hot and cold climates within eithe
r reproductive mode. The viviparous lizards were more successful at pr
oducing offspring, regardless of climatic conditions. Thus, viviparity
provided an advantage (in terms of embryo and/or neonate survival) un
der the conditions of the experiment, but this advantage was not restr
icted to cold environments.