Jm. Curran et al., THE INTERPRETATION OF ELEMENTAL COMPOSITION MEASUREMENTS FROM FORENSIC GLASS EVIDENCE .1., Science & justice, 37(4), 1997, pp. 241-244
Glass fragments are known to transfer to the clothing of a person brea
king a window. These fragments may be used as evidence, associating th
e breaker to the crime. Recent work in the characterization of glass e
vidence by its elemental composition has required a framework for the
evaluation of this data. Traditional treatment of the data involves de
termining the mean concentration and the standard deviation for each e
lement and then comparing the means using a '3 sigma rule' and testing
the match criteria with a strict range overlap for each of the elemen
ts. This paper will demonstrate a statistical test that has advantages
over the '3 sigma rule' approach.