IMMUNOSUPPRESSION AND NITRIC-OXIDE PRODUCTION INDUCED BY PARENTERAL LIVE SALMONELLA VACCINES DO NOT CORRELATE WITH PROTECTIVE CAPACITY - A PHOP--TN10 MUTANT DOES NOT SUPPRESS BUT DOES PROTECT
Tk. Eisenstein et al., IMMUNOSUPPRESSION AND NITRIC-OXIDE PRODUCTION INDUCED BY PARENTERAL LIVE SALMONELLA VACCINES DO NOT CORRELATE WITH PROTECTIVE CAPACITY - A PHOP--TN10 MUTANT DOES NOT SUPPRESS BUT DOES PROTECT, Vaccine, 16(1), 1998, pp. 24-32
Previous work from our laboratory showed that an aroA mutant strain of
S. typhimurium, SL3235, induces profound immunosuppression 7 days pos
t-parenteral inoculation, and that the suppression is mediated by nitr
ic oxide. Suppression was measured by the capacity of spleen cells to
mount a primary in vitro plaque-forming cell response to sheep red blo
od cells in Mishell-Dutton cultures. In the present studies, the capac
ity of a panel of strains of attenuated Salmonella with various geneti
c lesions was tested. Most of the strains were S. typhimurium, but sev
eral were S. dublin It was found that a variety of Salmonella strains
induced suppression, demonstrating that suppressive capacity is not un
ique to SL3235 or to S. typhimurium. A strong correlation was obtained
between the log(10) of the microbial burden (cfu spleen(-1)) on the s
eventh day post-vaccine inoculation and the degree of immunosuppressio
n. Strains that gave high spleen counts gave greater suppression. Micr
obial burden also correlated with the size of the spleen and the amoun
t of nitrite produced by spleen-cell cultures, a measure of nitric oxi
de. Finally, the degree of immunosuppression was found to be linearly
related to the log(10) of the amount of nitrate produced. The capacity
of the various strains of Salmonella to protect against challenge wit
h virulent S. typhimurium, strain W118-2, was also tested. No correlat
ion was found between suppressive and protective capacities of the var
ious strains. Two strains suppressed, but did not protect. While most
strains that protected grew or persisted in vivo, a phoP::Tn10 mutant
of S. typhimurium did not grow or persist; this phoP mutant did not ca
use immunosuppression, but gave 100% protection against challenge with
wild type S. typhimurium, suggesting that such mutants have advantage
ous properties as live vaccines. (C) 1997 Elsevier Science Ltd.