Ma. Brzezinski et Dr. Phillips, EVALUATION OF SI-32 AS A TRACER FOR MEASURING SILICA PRODUCTION-RATESIN MARINE WATERS, Limnology and oceanography, 42(5), 1997, pp. 856-865
The radioisotope Si-32 was evaluated as a tracer for measuring silica
production rates in marine waters. Si-32 is a weak beta-emitter that d
ecays to P-32 allowing the isotope to be used to determine simultaneou
sly the production rate of biogenic silica and organic phosphorus. Hig
h specific activity Si-32, 42,000-52,000 Bq (mu g Si)(-1), was produce
d by the proton spallation of KCl. Reasonable tracer additions result
in only nanomolar increases in the ambient silicic acid and orthophosp
hate concentrations during production rate experiments. Protocols for
quantifying the amount of Si-32 and P-32 in samples by liquid scintill
ation counting (LSC) and gas-flow proportional counting (GFPC) are pre
sented. Both protocols eliminate the 4-month wait for secular equilibr
ium between Si-32 and P-32 required by earlier methods. GFPC is especi
ally useful as the instrumentation is lightweight and portable allowin
g real-time analysis of samples at sea. Real-time analysis by GFPC at
sea and postcruise analysis by LSC gave results that agreed to within
17 and 7% for Si-32 and P-32, respectively. Subsequent intercalibratio
ns of the LSC and GFPC methods indicated that agreement to within 0.1-
4% for both isotopes can be achieved. Parallel incubations of samples
from Monterey Bay, California, using the radioisotope Si-32 and the st
able isotope Si-30 gave silica production rates that generally agreed
to within 30%. No significant bias was observed between rates obtained
with the two tracers. The greater sensitivity and ease of analysis of
the radioisotope makes Si-32 the tracer of choice for future studies
of silica production in the ocean.