Hmh. Hurks et al., DIFFERENTIAL-EFFECTS OF SUNSCREENS ON UVB-INDUCED IMMUNOMODULATION INHUMANS, Journal of investigative dermatology, 109(6), 1997, pp. 699-703
Ultraviolet radiation has been shown to suppress the (skin) immune sys
tem both in animal species and in humans, Whether sunscreens can preve
nt immunosuppression is a matter of debate. This study investigated th
e protective capacity of a commercial sunscreen lotion in humans. Part
of the right arm of healthy volunteers was exposed to erythemagenic u
ltraviolet B doses of 160 mJ per cm(2) for four consecutive days. Befo
re irradiation, sunscreen was applied either directly onto the skin or
onto a piece of quartz fixed to the skin (to avoid penetration of the
sunscreen in the epidermis where it cannot block the photoisomerizati
on of trans-urocanic acid in cis-urocanic acid in the stratum corneum)
. The control group was irradiated without prior application of sunscr
een, Four h after the last irradiation, epidermal sheets were obtained
by the suction-blister method from both arms and epidermal cells were
used as stimulator cells in the mixed epidermal cell lymphocyte react
ion, Responses directed to epidermal cells derived from irradiated ski
n were expressed as percentages of responses directed to epidermal cel
ls derived from the nonirradiated left arm, The mixed epidermal cell l
ymphocyte reaction responses in the control group were found to be sig
nificantly increased (205%). This enhancement of the mixed epidermal c
ell lymphocyte reaction responses was associated with an influx of CD3
6(+)DR(+) macrophages in the irradiated skin, Application of the sunsc
reen, either onto a piece of quartz or directly onto the skin, prevent
ed the increase of the mixed epidermal cell lymphocyte reaction respon
ses and the influx of CD36(+)DR(+) cells, In an earlier study, volunte
ers were exposed three times weekly to suberythemagenic doses of ultra
violet B over 4 wk, resulting in mixed epidermal cell lymphocyte react
ion responses that were decreased to 20%. The same sunscreen was not a
ble to prevent this suppression, These contradicting results indicate
that the protective effect of sunscreens with respect to ultraviolet-i
nduced immunomodulation is critically dependent on the choice of ultra
violet treatment.