Offering students opportunities to gain a strong sense of self, a posi
tive professional image, and a chance to articulate their clinical pra
ctice is a challenge for nurse educators. Writing journals in clinical
placements is one way in which students can create a dialogue with th
eir teacher and reflect upon and explore their clinical experiences in
the context in which these experiences occur. However, grading journa
ls according to numerous predetermined criteria can sabotage the benef
its and opportunities of writing journals. Judgment and control are tw
o aspects of evaluation and subsequent grading that can sabotage the b
enefits. Limiting predetermined criteria and not assigning grades to s
tudents' journals are two answers to this delicate issue.