Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis was used to evaluate
11 Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory-2 (MMPI-2) indicators o
f response distortion. College students who chose to simulate malinger
ing or defensive responding were offered a cash incentive for avoiding
detection. The responses of malingerers were compared with those of d
efendants undergoing pretrial evaluation and general psychiatric inpat
ients. The responses of defensive students were compared with those of
students who responded under standard instructions. Area under the RO
C curve (AUG) provided the index of discriminative power. In the detec
tion of malingering, F, F - K and, in 1 of 2 comparisons, F(p) produce
d significantly larger AUCs than other indices. Differences among indi
cators of defensiveness were generally small. However, the performance
of the S scale was promising, whereas F - K performed significantly w
orse than several other indices.