When the suitable habitat for a population is fragmented into relative
ly isolated patches, an individual's probability of success in interpa
tch migration may become low. If, in addition, the local demes inhabit
ing the patches experience random extinctions, the persistence of the
entire metapopulation can be threatened. A reduction in migration succ
ess results in natural selection, and given genetic variation in dispe
rsal-related traits, fragmentation may be followed by a change in disp
ersal behaviour and capacity, which in turn can influence the persiste
nce of the metapopulation. Using computer simulation, we investigate t
he consequences of genetic variation in dispersal-related traits for t
he probability of extinction following fragmentation. We find that wit
hin-deme selection against dispersal can set off a critical phase, dur
ing which the patch occupancy is low and the risk of extinction high.
In this manner, genetic variation can pose a threat to persistence. Ho
wever, if a metapopulation recovers from the critical phase, through r
ecolonization of empty patches by efficient dispersers, the ensuing pe
rsistence tends to be higher than would have been the case without gen
etic variation. The severity of a critical phase depends on factors li
ke the rapidity of the fragmentation process and the magnitude of the
drop in survival.