C. Ballard et al., THE UPDRS SCALE AS A MEANS OF IDENTIFYING EXTRAPYRAMIDAL SIGNS IN PATIENTS SUFFERING FROM DEMENTIA WITH LEWY BODIES, Acta neurologica Scandinavica, 96(6), 1997, pp. 366-371
The study aimed to evaluate the merits of the Unified Parkinson's Dise
ase Rating Scale (UPDRS) in the assessment of parkinsonism in patients
suffering from Dementia with Lewy Bodies (DLB). Parkinsonian symptoms
were assessed in 73 dementia patients using the UPDRS and staged usin
g the Hoehn & Yahr system. A staging of 1 or greater was taken to indi
cate significant parkinsonism. DLB (n=42) was diagnosed using the McKe
ith et al. criteria, Alzheimer's disease (n=30) was diagnosed using th
e NINCDS ADRDA criteria. The inability of some patients to comply with
some of the more complicated tasks meant that the full UPDRS assessme
nt could only be completed in 35 (83%) of the DLB patients, 23 (66%) o
f whom had significant parkinsonism. Patients with parkinsonism were s
ignificantly younger than those without, A Principal Components Analys
is derived a sub-scale including the items tremor al rest, action trem
or, bradykinesia, facial expression and rigidity, These items had a sp
ecificity of 100% and a sensitivity of 85% for significant parkinsonis
m using a cut-off of 7/8. The brief scale had several advantages over
the complete UPDS. Unlike the full scale it was independent of the sev
erity of cognitive impairment and the 5 key items could be assessed in
41 (98%) of the DLB patients. Autopsies have been completed on 31 pat
ients, with a specificity of greater than 90% for the operationalized
clinical diagnosis of DLB. It is suggested that a 5 item subscale of t
he UPDRS provides a reliable and generally applicable instrument for t
ile assessment of parkinsonism In DLB patients.