Public concerns about the quality of undergraduate education merit the
attention of research universities. This policy analysis documents st
andards of learning and teaching that fall far short of a liberal educ
ation in one department. It attributes the problem primarily to factor
s that obscure differences in standards, especially quantitative perfo
rmance measures. And it recommends liberating small working groups of
faculty volunteers to develop and distinguish courses that do raise st
andards. This prototyping strategy is an alternative to the status quo
, which is unsustainable, and a comprehensive, centrally-directed plan
, which is impractical. It may be adapted to similar situations elsewh
ere.