Recent critics of the secularization thesis have questioned the extent
to which premodern Britain was religious by creating a caricature of
a 'Golden Age of Faith' and then showing that the reality fell short o
f that image. This rejoinder stresses the need to appreciate the natur
e of religion pre-Reformation and draws on the work of leading histori
ans to show that, even if we accept the most jaundiced view of religio
n before and shortly after the Reformation, the previous orthodoxy was
more accurate than the recent revisions. In Laslett's phrase, 'the wo
rld we have lost' was a religious world.