The effect of marine reserve protection on coral reef fish communities
was studied on five islands located in the southwest lagoon of New Ca
ledonia. Commercial fish communities and Chaetodontidae, sampled befor
e fishing prohibition and after five years of protection, were compare
d. Reference stations were also sampled to assess variability in unpro
tected communities on the same time scale. The hypothesis that marine
reserves protect and develop fish stocks was confirmed. Species richne
ss, density and biomass of fish on the protected reefs increased respe
ctively by 67%, 160% and 246%. This increase was statistically signifi
cant, whereas the reference stations showed only a small increase in d
ensity. There were significant increases in the species richness, dens
ity and biomass of the major exploited fish families (Serranidae, Lutj
anidae, Lethrinidae, Mullidae, Labridae, Scaridae, Siganidae and Acant
huridae) and also of the Chaetodontidae. No significant increase in th
e mean lengths of fishes was noted among the main species, with the ex
ception of one species of Siganid. Size structure changed for most of
the main species, as the proportion of small individuals increased aft
er five years of protection. Detrended correspondance analysis indicat
ed that marine reserve protection was the most important determinant o
f the fish community structure. The second determinant was the positio
n along an inshore-offshore gradient. Marine reserve protection result
ed in an increase in the relative abundance and species richness of la
rge edible species within the assemblages.