Are generational accounts informative about the effect of the budget o
n the intergenerational distribution of resources and on aggregate sav
ing? First, the usefulness of generational accounts lives or dies with
the strict lifecycle model of household consumption. Second, even if
the life-cycle model holds, generational accounts ignore the intergene
rational redistribution associated with the government's provision of
public goods and services and with intergenerational externalities. Th
ird, generational accounting ignores the effect of the budget on tax a
nd transfer bases and on before-tax and -transfer quantities and price
s. That is, it does not handle incidence or general equilibrium reperc
ussions.