Numerical experiments have been performed to study the geometric colli
sion rate of finite-size particles with zero inertia (i.e., fluid elem
ents) in isotropic turbulence. The turbulent flow was generated by the
pseudospectral method. We argue that the formulation of Saffman and T
urner [J. Fluid Mech. 1, 16 (1956)] for the average collision kernel i
s correct only under the assumptions that the particles are kept in th
e system after collision and allowed to overlap in space. This was con
firmed, for the first time, by numerical experiments to within a numer
ical uncertainty as small as 1%. Finite corrections to the Saffman and
Turner result must be made if one applies the theory to actual coagul
ation process where particles are not allowed to overlap before collis
ion and particles are removed from a given size group after collision.
This is due to the fact that Saffman and Turner assumed a uniform, ti
me-independent concentration field in their formulation of the average
collision kernel, while in the actual modeling of population evolutio
n the particle number concentration changes in time and may be locally
nonuniform as a result of a biased removal process due to spatially n
onuniform coagulation rates. However, the quantitative level of the de
viations from the Saffman and Turner result remain to be explained. Nu
merical experiments in simple shear flow were also conducted to elabor
ate our findings. (C) 1998 American Institute of Physics.