Le. Borg et al., CONSTRAINTS ON MARTIAN DIFFERENTIATION PROCESSES FROM RB-SR AND SM-NDISOTOPIC ANALYSES OF THE BASALTIC SHERGOTTITE QUE-94201, Geochimica et cosmochimica acta, 61(22), 1997, pp. 4915-4931
Isotopic analyses of mineral, leachate, and whole rock fractions from
the Martian shergottite meteorite QUE 94201 yield Rb-Sr and Sm-Nd crys
tallization ages of 327 +/- 12 and 327 +/- 19 Ma, respectively. These
ages are concordant, although the isochrons are defined by different f
ractions within the meteorite. Comparison of isotope dilution Sm and N
d data for the various QUE 94201 fractions with in situ ion microprobe
data for QUE 94201 minerals from the literature demonstrate the prese
nce of a leachable crustal component in the meteorite. This component
is likely to have been added to QUE 94201 by secondary alteration proc
esses on Mars and can affect the isochrons by selectively altering the
isotopic systematics of the leachates and some of the mineral fractio
ns. Initial Sr-87/Sr-86 Of 0.701298 +/- 14, epsilon(Nd)(143) Of +47.6
+/- 1.7, and whole rock epsilon(Nd)(142) Of +0.92 +/- 0.11 indicate th
at QUE 94201 was derived from a source that was strongly depleted in R
b-87/Sr-86 and enriched in Sm-147/Nd-144 early in its history. Modelin
g demonstrates that the Sm-Nd isotopic compositions of QUE 94201 can b
e produced by either four episodes of melting at 327 Ma of cumulates c
rystallized from a magma ocean at 4.525 Ga or five episodes of melting
of an initially solid Mars at 4.525 Ga and 327 Ma. The neodymium isot
opic systematics of QUE 94201 are not consistent with significant melt
ing between 4.525 Ga and 327 Ma. The estimated timing of these events
is based on initial neodymium isotopic ratios and is independent of di
fferentiation of the QUE 94201 parental magma, Rb-Sr-based partial mel
ting models are unable to reproduce the composition of QUE 94201 using
the same model parameters employed in the Sm-Nd-based models, implyin
g a decoupling of Rb-Sr and Sm-Nd isotopic systems. The initial decoup
ling of the two isotopic systems can be attributed to either cumulate
or crust formation processes which are able to more efficiently fracti
onate Rb from Sr compared to Sm from Nd. The fact that all Martian met
eorites analyzed so far define a Rb-Sr whole rock isochron age of 4.5
Ga suggests that virtually all Rb was partitioned out of their mantle
source regions and into either fractionated residual liquids trapped i
n the cumulate pile or into the crust at that time. Thus, the Martian
mantle cumulates and restites are not expected to evolve past Sr-87/Sr
-86 Of 0.700 and could not have been significantly enriched in incompa
tible elements by crustal recycling processes. All Martian meteorites
have initial Sr-87/Sr-86 values that are higher than similar to 0.700
and are, therefore, likely to be produced by mixing between evolved cr
ustal-like and depleted mantle reservoirs. The absence of crustal recy
cling processes on Mars may preserve the geochemical evidence for deco
upling of the Rb-Sr and Sm-Nd isotopic systems, underscoring one of th
e fundamental differences between geologic processes on Mars and the E
arth. Copyright (C) 1997 Elsevier Science Ltd.