Se. Carty et al., CONCISE PARATHYROIDECTOMY - THE IMPACT OF PREOPERATIVE SPECT TC-99M SESTAMIBI SCANNING AND INTRAOPERATIVE QUICK PARATHORMONE ASSAY, Surgery, 122(6), 1997, pp. 1107-1114
Background, Results of initial operation for sporadic primary hyperpar
athyroidism are generally excellent, lent, yet today there is pressure
to improve outcome and resource utilization. Methods. We designed a p
rospective longitudinal cohort study comparing two approaches to conci
se parathyroidectomy. Strategy A was defined as the palpation method f
or selective unilateral exploration. Strategy B was defined as the rou
tine use of both preoperative Tc-99m sestamibi single photon emission
computed tomography (SPECT) imaging and intraoperative quick parathorm
one assay. With either strategy the study period was 19 months and pat
ients explored unilaterally were candidates for same-day discharge. We
compared surgical outcome for 128 consecutive consenting patients eac
h with 6 months or more of follow-up (mean 12 +/- 7.6 months). Results
. Demographic, biochemical, and pathologic findings did not differ bet
ween groups. SPECT imaging precisely localized hyperfunctioning parath
yroid tissue. Compared with Strategy A (n = 61), the 67 patients treat
ed by use of Strategy B experienced a higher rate of unilateral explor
ation (41.0% versus 62.7%, p < 0.00001) and a shorter length of stay (
1.07 versus 1.90 days, p < 0.00001) and trended to have shorter operat
ive times, fewer operative failures, and less morbidity. Total periope
rative costs did not differ between groups. Conclusions, Routine use o
f intraoperative quick parathormone measurement and preoperative Tc-99
m sestamibi SPECT is as safe, effective, and cost-effective as convent
ional approaches to parathyroidectomy. Use of this strategy is associa
ted with significant reductions in extent of surgery and length of hos
pital stay.