We consider a common-property resource sold in imperfectly competitive
markets. There is a dynamic externality (current harvests lower futur
e stocks, raising future harvest costs) and a static (crowding) extern
ality. Increasing industry size raises costs but lowers prices; thus,
it has ambiguous welfare effects. The optimal industry size typically
changes over time, so that a first-best outcome cannot be obtained wit
h a fixed number of firms. Single-firm exploitation is optimal only un
der special circumstances. The socially optimal open-loop steady-state
industry size corresponds to the static optimum; both generally diffe
r from the closed-loop steady-state optimum.