A. Bucklin et al., GENE FLOW PATTERNS OF THE EUPHAUSIID, MEGANYCTIPHANES-NORVEGICA, IN THE NW ATLANTIC BASED ON MTDNA SEQUENCES FOR CYTOCHROME-B AND CYTOCHROME-OXIDASE-I, Journal of plankton research, 19(11), 1997, pp. 1763-1781
Population genetic structure and patterns of gene flow are described f
or the euphausiid, Meganyctiphanes norvegica, in the NW Atlantic Ocean
based on DNA sequence variation of two regions of mitochondrial DNA (
mtDNA). DNA sequences were determined for portions of cytochrome oxida
se I (COI; 400 base pairs; 76 individuals) and cytochrome b (CYB; 300
base pairs; 101 individuals) for euphausiids collected from the Gulf o
f Maine in 1991, the Gulf of St Lawrence in 1993 and 1994, the Scotian
Shelf in 1994, and Georges Bank in 1994. For comparison, M.norvegica
collected from the fjords of western Norway in 1992 were sequenced for
COI (20 individuals) and CYB (18 individuals). COI was less variable
than CYB, based on both haplotype (h = 0.6847 for COI; 0.9077 for CYB)
and nucleotide diversities (pi = 0.0038 for COI; 0.0182 for CYB). Hap
lotype frequencies among all samples of M.norvegica were significantly
heterogeneous for CYB (P < 0.001 by chi(2)), COI/CYB (P < 0.034) and
for the 37 sites in the COI/CYB sequence at which there were multiple
substitutions (MSUB; P < 0.0001). Haplotype frequencies among regional
populations (i.e. pooled samples collected within each region) in the
NW Atlantic were different for MSUB haplotypes (P < 0.021), but not f
or any other gene portion. Comparison of NW Atlantic versus Norwegian
fjord populations (based on pooled samples) revealed significant diffe
rences in haplotype frequencies for CYB (P < 0.004) and MSUB (P < 0.00
01), and by analysis of molecular variance (AMOVA) for CYB (P < 0.01)
and COI (P < 0.01). All evidence considered together indicated that: (
i) genetic heterogeneity among samples reflected high levels of molecu
lar genetic diversity and, perhaps, undersampling of the population ge
netic structure; (ii) gene flow of M.norvegica within the NW Atlantic
was sufficient to prevent the formation of distinctive geographical po
pulations, except in the case of the Gulf of St Lawrence sample collec
ted in 1994; (iii) genetic differentiation of NW Atlantic and Norwegia
n fjord populations indicated highly restricted gene how across the N
Atlantic Ocean. We conclude that mtDNA genes may vary significantly in
the amount and pattern of variation, and that this variation affects
the results and conclusions from molecular population genetic analyses
. Consideration of genetic traits with small numbers of moderately fre
quent variants, such as the MSUB haplotypes, markedly increased the po
wer of statistical analyses. Resolution of the population genetic stru
cture of marine zooplankton at spatial scales smaller than ocean basin
s will require the analysis of numerous individuals (i.e. thousands),
samples collected at appropriate temporal and spatial resolutions, and
molecular markers with appropriate levels and patterns of variation.