Hj. Naauwynck et al., VIROLOGICAL PROTECTION OF SOWS UPON CHALLENGE WITH AUJESZKYS-DISEASE VIRUS AFTER MULTIPLE VACCINATIONS WITH ATTENUATED OR INACTIVATED VACCINES, Journal of veterinary medicine. Series B, 44(10), 1997, pp. 609-615
The frequency with which sows are vaccinated during eradication progra
mmes has been determined rather arbitrarily in the past, without the n
ecessary scientific support. In the present study the efficacy of repe
ated vaccinations against Aujeszky's disease virus (ADV) with two inac
tivated vaccines and with one attenuated ADV-strain (Bartha) suspended
in either oil-in-water or saline was evaluated in 40 breeding sows or
iginating from five farms by the assessment of the clinical and virolo
gical protection upon an experimental challenge. Sows with two differe
nt histories of number of booster vaccinations after a base immunizati
on were selected: young sows which had received 1-3 booster vaccinatio
ns and old sows which had received 8-10 booster vaccinations. Two sero
negative and two gE-positive sows were included as controls. After cha
llenge, clinical signs such as anorexia and fever were observed in the
two seronegative sows and only in four out of the 18 sows which had r
epeatedly been vaccinated with inactivated vaccines. The mean duration
of virus-excretion significantly differed (P < 0.05) between the expe
rimental groups. In seronegative sows, virus shedding lasted for 12.5
days. This period was reduced to 6.8-7.9 days in the groups of sows va
ccinated with inactivated vaccines having no effect by the number of b
ooster vaccinations and type of vaccine. In the groups of sows vaccina
ted with Bartha vaccine, challenge virus was detected during 3.7-5.3 d
ays when revaccinated 1-3 times. A reduction to 0.7-1.2 days was obtai
ned with a higher number of boosters (8-10) but only when the vaccine
virus was suspended in o/w. Considering the mean cumulative values of
virus excretion (area under the curve) it can be stated that sows freq
uently vaccinated with inactivated vaccines excrete significantly (P <
0.05) higher amounts of virus (26.0-31.5) than sows frequently vaccin
ated with attenuated ones (1.6-23.7). We may conclude from the present
data that the attenuated vaccine virus Bartha, especially when suspen
ded in o/w is superior to inactivated vaccines for inducing clinical a
nd virological protection of sows in the field during their whole bree
ding period.